The Cayero Group

An independent insurance brokerage in Morristown, New Jersey.

What We Do

At The Cayero Group, we make insurance simple. Whether you’re protecting your home, business, or high-value property, our team is here to guide you through the process. We specialize in covering everything from coastal homes and rental properties to commercial spaces and hard to place risks, always with top-notch service. We’re not just here to sell policies; we’re here to be a trusted resource, making sure you feel confident and protected every step of the way.

Learn more
Modern hotel lobby with seating areas, large green trees, and decorative ceiling lights.

Service That Puts You First

We take the time to walk you through all your options, answer your questions, and make sure you actually understand what you’re getting. Our team is responsive, approachable, and truly invested in making sure you feel taken care of — not just when you sign, but whenever you need us.

Coverage Areas

A gray sports sedan car with black rims on a green background.
A modern two-story house with a gray and white exterior, brown accents, a front porch, and a two-car garage
Modern multi-story apartment building with balconies, large windows, and a landscaped ground area with trees.
A white and black motorboat with a canopy and seating area, floating on water.
Learn more
Black cruiser motorcycle with chrome accents on a green background.

Home

-

Auto

-

High-Net-Worth

-

Collections

-

Business

-

Commercial

-

Boat

-

Motorcycle

-

Umbrella

-

Coastal Properties

-

Natural Disaster

-

RVs

-

Rental Properties

-

Home - Auto - High-Net-Worth - Collections - Business - Commercial - Boat - Motorcycle - Umbrella - Coastal Properties - Natural Disaster - RVs - Rental Properties -

Meet our team

  • Cartoon illustration of a man with a beard, short brown hair, wearing a white shirt, against a dark green background.

    Joe Cayero

    Principal Broker

  • A cartoon illustration of a smiling man with brown hair, wearing a dark blue suit jacket and white shirt, set against a green background.

    Charlie Farrell

    Account Executive

  • Cartoon illustration of a man with short brown hair, wearing a black suit, white shirt, and black tie, smiling in front of a green background.

    Dominic Molendyke

    Account Executive

  • Cartoon image of a smiling man with brown curly hair wearing a dark blazer and a white shirt against a green background.

    Jack Lazarus

    Account Executive

  • Illustration of a woman with long brown hair, smiling, wearing a white top and a delicate necklace, against a green background.

    Grace Rubinstein

    Operations Manager

  • Cartoon illustration of a smiling man with blond hair, wearing a white collared shirt against a dark green background.

    Ben Cayero

    Regional Account Manager

Learn more

Get in Touch

Find us at

89 Headquarters Plaza
14th Floor
Morristown, NJ 07960

Can’t make it to the office? No problem! Reach us via call, text, or email at any time.

joe.cayero@thecayerogroup.com
(908) 864-2922

 

Get started with The Cayero Group, today.

Get a Quote